This chapter from The Count of Monte Cristo revolves around a tense and dramatic conversation between Villefort, the public prosecutor, and Dr. d'Avrigny, a physician deeply troubled by the mysterious deaths occurring in Villefort’s household. The chapter explores the themes of guilt, justice, and the burden of knowledge, revealing the escalating horror as Villefort is confronted with the possibility that someone within his family is a murderer.
The scene opens with Villefort in a state of shock after witnessing the death of Barrois, an old servant, which Dr. d'Avrigny diagnoses as another murder within the house. Villefort, overwhelmed by terror, grief, and a sense of impending madness, struggles to cope with the realization that death has become a recurring presence in his home. The doctor, however, insists that these deaths are not mere accidents but deliberate crimes, and urges Villefort to take action before more lives are lost.
Dr. d'Avrigny hints that someone in Villefort’s household is a “frightful monstrosity,” comparing the situation to historical figures known for their cruelty and evil deeds. He draws a parallel between the crimes committed in Villefort’s home and those of infamous female poisoners in history, such as Locusta and Agrippina, suggesting that the culprit is someone unsuspected but dangerously close.
Villefort, horrified by the doctor’s implications, resists the idea that someone he loves could be responsible. Yet, as Dr. d'Avrigny methodically recounts the suspicious deaths—starting with M. de Saint-Méran, followed by Madame de Saint-Méran, and now the attempted murder of Noirtier—Villefort can no longer deny the possibility. The doctor reveals that the poison used in the murders matches the symptoms he has observed and that Noirtier survived because he had been gradually accustomed to a similar poison, brucine, as part of his medical treatment.
The doctor accuses Valentine, Villefort’s daughter, of being the poisoner, noting her involvement in preparing medicines and drinks for the victims. Villefort is devastated by the accusation and pleads with the doctor to show mercy. He cannot bring himself to believe that Valentine, whom he views as pure and innocent, could be capable of such heinous acts. Villefort’s anguish is palpable as he begs the doctor not to pursue the matter further, fearing the loss of his daughter and the destruction of his family’s honor.
Dr. d'Avrigny, however, remains firm, insisting that the crimes must be brought to light and that the poisoner must face justice. He tells Villefort that if he continues to protect the culprit, the consequences will only grow worse, potentially leading to more deaths within the family. Despite Villefort’s desperate pleas, the doctor is resolute in his decision to step back from the situation, refusing to be complicit in further cover-ups or to attend to any more illnesses in the household.
The chapter ends with the servants in Villefort’s home deciding to leave, driven away by the fear that death has taken residence in the house. Villefort, observing their departure, is caught between his love for his daughter and the dreadful suspicion that she might be responsible for the deaths. As the servants express their sorrow at leaving, particularly for Valentine, Villefort notices a fleeting, ominous smile on Madame de Villefort’s lips, adding another layer of mystery and foreboding to the already dark atmosphere.
This chapter is crucial in escalating the tension within the narrative, as Villefort is forced to confront the possibility that his daughter is guilty of murder, and Dr. d'Avrigny refuses to allow the crimes to go unpunished. The moral and emotional dilemmas faced by Villefort highlight the novel’s exploration of justice, retribution, and the complexities of human nature.